Stop Using Frontier AI for Everything: The Tiered Model Strategy

📚 More on this topic: Ollama Troubleshooting Guide · llama.cpp vs Ollama vs vLLM · VRAM Requirements · Budget AI PC Under $500

If you’re using Claude Opus or GPT-4 to check file syntax, format JSON, or answer “what’s the capital of France?” — you’re burning money.

Frontier models cost 60x more than their smaller siblings. Most tasks don’t need that power. This guide shows you how to build a tiered AI strategy that uses the right model for each task, saving hundreds of dollars a month without sacrificing quality where it matters.

The Problem: Frontier Models for Everything

Here’s what happens when you use Opus/GPT-4 for everything:

Simple question: “What’s the syntax for a Python list comprehension?”

• Haiku cost: $0.0003
• Opus cost: $0.02
• Overpay: 67x

Format this JSON:

• Local model cost: $0
• Opus cost: $0.01
• Overpay: ∞

Analyze this architecture and identify security vulnerabilities:

• Haiku: Misses subtle issues
• Opus: Catches everything
• Right tool for the job

The pattern is clear: frontier models are overkill for 80% of tasks, but essential for the remaining 20%.

The Tiered Model Hierarchy

Cost Comparison

Running 1,000 tasks (average 2K tokens each):

Tiered approach saves 88% vs all-Opus while maintaining quality where needed.

Tier 1: Local Models (Free)

Local models running on your own hardware cost nothing per query. The only cost is electricity (~$0.01/hour for an RTX 3060).

What Local Models Handle Well

Recommended Local Models

Setup: Install Ollama and run ollama pull llama3.1:8b. Done.

Local Model Limitations

Don’t use local for:

• Complex reasoning chains
• Nuanced analysis
• Security-critical decisions
• Tasks requiring broad knowledge
• Anything where being wrong has consequences

Tier 2: Fast/Cheap Cloud (Haiku, GPT-4o mini)

When local isn’t confident enough but you don’t need heavy reasoning.

Haiku/Mini Sweet Spot

Cost at This Tier

When to escalate up: Model says “I’m not sure” or gives clearly wrong answers.

Tier 3: Capable Models (Sonnet, GPT-4o)

Your workhorse tier. Handles 80% of real work tasks.

Sonnet/GPT-4o Sweet Spot

Cost at This Tier

When to escalate up: High-stakes decisions, security, architecture, legal.

Tier 4: Frontier Models (Opus, GPT-4, o1)

Reserve for tasks where being wrong is expensive.

When Frontier Is Worth It

Cost at This Tier

The math: Even at 60x the cost of Haiku, 10 critical tasks per day = $1.80/day = $54/month. Cheap insurance.

The Escalation Pattern

Start cheap. Escalate only when needed.

Task arrives
    ↓
Can local handle it? (formatting, syntax, basic lookup)
    → Yes: Use local (free)
    → No: Continue
    ↓
Is it simple reasoning? (classification, basic Q&A)
    → Yes: Use Haiku/mini (~$0.001/task)
    → No: Continue
    ↓
Is it standard work? (coding, analysis, writing)
    → Yes: Use Sonnet/GPT-4o (~$0.02/task)
    → No: Continue
    ↓
Is it critical? (security, architecture, high-stakes)
    → Yes: Use Opus/GPT-4 (~$0.20/task)

Automatic Escalation Signals

Escalate when the current tier:

• Says “I’m not confident”
• Gives an obviously wrong answer
• Produces inconsistent output
• Can’t follow complex instructions
• Misses context from earlier in conversation

Practical Routing Examples

Example 1: Code Review Pipeline

Total for typical PR: $0.02-0.22 (vs $0.80+ if all Opus)

Example 2: Documentation Generation

Total: ~$0.04 per function documented

Example 3: Bug Investigation

Total: $0.04-0.24 depending on criticality

Example 4: AI Coding Agent (Claude Code, Cursor, etc.)

Most AI coding tools let you choose models. Smart routing:

When to Always Use Frontier

Some tasks should never be cheap-routed:

Always Opus/GPT-4

The 10x Rule

If fixing a mistake costs 10x more than the API call difference, use frontier.

• Opus costs $0.20 more than Sonnet for a task
• Fixing a security bug in production costs $2,000 (incident response, patching, customer communication)
• Use Opus.

Setting Up a Tiered Workflow

For Individual Developers

1. Install Ollama for local models: curl -fsSL https://ollama.com/install.sh | sh
2. Pull a local model: ollama pull llama3.1:8b
3. Use local for: file checks, formatting, basic questions
4. Use Sonnet/GPT-4o for: daily coding work
5. Use Opus for: anything security-related or architectural

For API Users

Route requests programmatically:

def select_model(task_type, is_critical=False):
    if is_critical:
        return "claude-opus-4"

    simple_tasks = ["format", "syntax", "lookup", "classify"]
    medium_tasks = ["code", "analyze", "write", "debug"]

    if task_type in simple_tasks:
        return "claude-3-5-haiku-latest"
    elif task_type in medium_tasks:
        return "claude-sonnet-4-20250514"
    else:
        return "claude-opus-4"

For AI Agents

Configure your agent to use tiered models:

# Example agent config
models:
  file_operations: ollama/llama3.1:8b
  simple_reasoning: claude-3-5-haiku-latest
  coding: claude-sonnet-4-20250514
  critical: claude-opus-4

routing:
  - pattern: "read file|list directory|check syntax"
    model: file_operations
  - pattern: "is this|classify|simple question"
    model: simple_reasoning
  - pattern: "security|auth|payment|architecture"
    model: critical
  - default: coding

Cost Savings Calculator

Before (All Frontier)

After (Tiered)

Common Mistakes

Mistake 1: Routing Everything to Local

Local models are free but limited. Using them for complex reasoning leads to:

• Wrong answers that waste your time
• Bugs that cost more to fix than the API call
• Frustration with “AI doesn’t work”

Fix: Use local for mechanical tasks only.

Mistake 2: Fear of Frontier Costs

Avoiding Opus for security reviews to save $0.20 is false economy when a missed vulnerability costs thousands.

Fix: Always use frontier for critical tasks.

Mistake 3: No Escalation Path

Using Haiku and accepting bad answers instead of escalating.

Fix: When a model says “I’m not sure,” escalate immediately.

Mistake 4: Context Bloat

Sending 50K tokens of context to Opus when Sonnet with 10K tokens would suffice.

Fix: Trim context aggressively. Smaller context = faster + cheaper.

The Bottom Line

The tiered model strategy:

1. Local (free): File operations, formatting, basic lookups
2. Haiku ($0.25/M): Simple reasoning, classification
3. Sonnet ($3/M): Daily coding work, analysis
4. Opus ($15/M): Security, architecture, critical decisions

The rules:

• Start at the cheapest tier that might work
• Escalate when confidence drops
• Always use frontier for high-stakes tasks
• Don’t penny-pinch on security

The math:

• Tiered routing saves 80-90% vs all-frontier
• Even heavy users spend <$400/month with smart routing
• The savings pay for a dedicated local AI setup in 2 months

Build the habit of asking “what tier does this task need?” before every AI interaction. Your API bill will thank you.

Related Guides

• Ollama Troubleshooting Guide
• llama.cpp vs Ollama vs vLLM
• VRAM Requirements for Local LLMs
• Budget AI PC Under $500
• How Much Does It Cost to Run LLMs Locally
• Local LLMs vs ChatGPT